Is Earth as Special as We Think?

 Earth's sunlit face captured this summer by cameras aboard the DSCOVR satellite. This pretty blue marble may be ripe for life, but it may not be so special. (NASA)

Earth's sunlit face captured this summer by cameras aboard the DSCOVR satellite. This pretty blue marble may be ripe for life, but it may not be so special. (NASA)

Maybe Earth isn't so special. "We could have easily been standing on Venus having this conversation," says Mark Jellinek, a geologist who studies how planets form.

I envision standing under Venus' thick atmosphere of greenhouse gases, broiling on the dusty planet's surface. Temperatures there soar high enough to melt lead. Sure, Venus and Earth are often said to be the most comparable planets—similar in size, makeup, and distance from the sun—but "easily" seems like a stretch.

Or maybe not. According to recent research, if we restart the "experiment" of our solar system, seemingly insignificant early changes—like internal heat, climate, or water content—could completely reroute planetary history, says Adrian Lenardic, a planetary scientist at Rice University.

Maybe a rewind would lead to life on Venus instead of Earth; or maybe life on neither. After all, scientists are now learning, there might be much more to our balmy climate than Earth's perfectly-sized bulk circling our fiery sun at just the right distance. We cannot ignore a planet's history: "How it got to be where it is; how it started out; how it evolved over time," Lenardic explains.

On Earth, that tipping point could have been a period of intense meteorite impacts, argues Jellinek, of the University of British Columbia, in a recent study in the journal Nature Geoscience. These impacts would have helped exfoliate heat-producing radioactive elements on Earth's surface, allowing the planet to cool, and meanwhile jumpstarting a driver of Earth's internal thermostat, known as plate tectonics.

Habitability is also not permanent.

On Mars, the river channels and dried lake beds discovered there suggest the now-dusty planet had an ancient watery past. Perhaps life once creeped in those waters. And who knows? "Venus could have been a very habitable planet for quite some time," says Lenardic. (Learn fun facts about Venus.)

So what is the latest recipe for a habitable planet? The ingredients might surprise you.

Oven Temperature

To host an Earth-like menagerie and luscious vegetation, scientists have long said that planets need to fall within the so-called habitable zone. This swath of space exists at a "Goldilocks" distance from a star, where a planet is warmed just enough for liquid water to flow.

"At some level, no one argues with that," says Lenardic. The idea is rather intuitive: Approach a sizzling star too closely, and the planet incinerates; move too far away and the world freezes over.

But it's more complicated than that. For instance: how far from a star is the habitable zone? That depends how hot the star is.

And then there's the size of the planet. Too small and the planet's atmosphere escapes its gravity and is lost to space. Too large and the atmosphere becomes thick and "puffy," says Cowan, with potential to become a freezing giant like Neptune and Uranus.

Discoveries from NASA's Kepler telescope—launched in 2009 to seek out worlds ripe for life—show that a planet up to 1.5 Earth radii may be habitable, says Nick Cowan, a planetary scientist at McGill University.

Of the 1,030 planets (and counting) Kepler has identified, a handful meet the Goldilocks standards for both size and distance, with Kepler 452b perhaps the most similar to Earth.  

But these qualities alone do not make a habitable place. And a growing cohort of scientists believe the recipe is much more complex.

A Perfect Crust

Earth's outer surface is flexible: It pulls and pushes, driven by the churning inner Earth, known as mantle convection. Sometime in geologic history—it is much debated when—this tug-of-war cracked the surface into a series of creeping plates.

But why do they matter? The plates are part of Earth's thermostat. Their collisions stoke volcanic eruptions, which "burp" the greenhouse gasses necessary for atmosphere. And as Earth gets "hot under the collar," the collisions pull extra gas back down into its depths, says Cowan.

Earth is the only planet known with a system of actively creeping plates, a process called tectonics, and according to Jellinek, it is what truly sets us apart.

Read the full story at National Geographic

SpaceMaya Wei-HaasPlanets